
1. In the introduction, you describe modern relationship advice as having “failed spectacularly.” What do you believe it gets most wrong about love today?
Love in the great abstract sounds easy, but when sex gets into the mix we suddenly find ourselves confronted with all sorts of deep-seated fears, which for the most part come down from our evolution. Evolutionary psychology has brought unique insights into our sexuality, but in its decades of existence it hasn’t quite penetrated the mainstream. Moreover, mainstream advice either completely stays away from any religious or cultural tradition, or pushes just one tradition. Yet many human cultures have devised ways of managing these problems, although not always very well. So mainstream relationship advice fails doubly by not appreciating the depth of the problem, and by ignoring much practical and spiritual advice as “not invented here.”
2. You name four internal enemies of intimacy—violence, pettiness, vanity, and agenda. Why did you choose these four specifically, and how do they build on one another throughout the book?
This is inspired by Chogyam Trungpa’s Shambhala teachings on spiritual warriorship, or how to engage the world with an open heart. He names the “four dignities” of the warrior as meekness, perkiness, outrageousness, and inscrutability. On any spiritual path, one needs to work with the coarsest obstacles before the need for subtler work is felt. For example, there has been talk about consent for some time, which is unquestionably a good thing, but now we also begin to see that consent isn’t the be-all and end-all of good relationships.
3.In Part One, you expand the definition of “violence” to include coercion, ghosting, digital abuse, and emotional manipulation. Why was it important to broaden the term beyond physical harm?
We all think we are nice people. We need to look deeper in order to become thoroughly lovable.
4.You argue that we must take ownership of our state of mind even when others hurt us. How do you balance personal responsibility with acknowledging systemic or structural challenges?
We do what we can, but this isn’t about turning the other cheek exactly. We need to shift the perspective from winning or being right, to keeping our heart open, even and especially if we are hurt or need to act forcefully. If we have enemies, preserving our humanity means retaining at least a bit of compassion for them, even if it’s hard. In particular, people complain about the opposite sex all over the Internet. The energy would be better spent if we were all looking at our own faults, even if we think they are slight.
5.You introduce ho‘oponopono as a forgiveness practice. What role does forgiveness play in developing authentic intimacy?
I came across this practice as I was facing a terrible adversarial situation and was astonished how effective it was. It is all about restoring our humanity, as opposed to keeping permanent grudges. Hawaiian culture places a very high value on communal harmony and mutual responsibility. Forgiveness doesn’t mean letting someone off the hook easily. The traditional form of Ho’oponopono also entails restitution, as needed.
6.In Part Two, you describe pettiness as treating love like emotional comfort or a transaction. How does modern convenience culture reinforce this mindset?
Ha! You just answered it. Nothing in a convenient society can quite model the messiness of our relationships.
7.You discuss evolutionary psychology and mate retention behaviors like jealousy and scorekeeping. How can readers recognize when these instincts are sabotaging their relationships?
The hard part is to be willing to examine one’s attitude carefully, and then weigh it against the situation. Am I being jealous or possessive because of my partner, or am I just being insecure? In my last book, from which The Authentic Young Lover is derived, a contemplation asks the reader to imagine their beloved in someone else’s arms, and moreover, to wish them well. It takes effort to confront those fears, but actually there is no harm. It’s all benefit.
8.Grace is presented as the antidote to pettiness. What does grace look like in everyday relationship conflicts?
A lot of relationship talk is about trading all sorts of reassurances, for fear that it might all end or go sideways. Wouldn’t it be nice to just be together, feeling secure in the moment but not trying to guarantee it?
9.You revisit medieval courtly love as a model of sincerity, moderation, and equality. What lessons from that tradition are most relevant to dating in the app era?
Equality for sure! This “princess treatment” meme is so over the top! Seriously, grace (or courtliness) is really about a robust ethic paired with magnanimity, and the idea that we do not love merely to feel good, but because of the possibility of deep enrichment for both partners.
10.In your chapter on “How to Kiss Like in the Movies,” you propose the “90% rule.” How does this approach resolve the tension between consent and spontaneity?
I’ve always seen the tension as first between rushing to, and waiting too long for a first kiss; then between asking and going with the flow. If you take the nonverbal approach and go 90% of the way toward the other, then the issue of consent is moot. Or do you need consent to be in someone’s face for a brief moment? Developing a warm rapport first is really the best way to prevent awkwardness.
11.In Part Three, you unpack attractiveness hierarchies and the competitive dating marketplace. How do dating apps amplify vanity and disposability?
Dating apps, especially the mostly visual ones like Tinder naturally amplify a preoccupation with attractiveness. But my main peeve with online dating is the illusion that we just need to pick someone with the right characteristics and all will be well. Not only Tinder and the like, but even a supposedly serious and scientific outfit like eHarmony haven’t cracked that puzzle and probably never will. Love requires engagement and vulnerability, not choosiness or a clever algorithm.
12.You describe modern dating culture as a “peacock display.” What is the cost of constantly performing attractiveness and status?
We can all ask ourselves: why am I doing all this? Who am I trying to impress? It is not only exhausting. We puff ourselves up and end up finding no one attractive enough for us. The numbers in Kenrick’s research imply that much.
13.You argue that charm is the alternative to vanity. How would you define charm in contrast to performance?
At first blush I would say charm doesn’t look like anything. It is our confidence without reference point. Not confident in any particular quality or ability, just confidence. It hangs just like that, on its own, for the mere fact that we are human, should we care to notice it. The word “charm” is interesting in that is conjures up some idea of magic. The magic is that we don’t need anything to be confident in.
14.In Part Four, you address “agenda” as using relationships to fix loneliness or fulfill scripts. How can readers tell when they’re loving someone versus using someone?
The agenda runs deep and it is very hard to do the subject justice in a short book. I talk about it more in the other book, and it gets quite abstract. But in short, we need to remember that romantic love, selfless as it may be, exists in tension with our reproduction, which is not pretty and wants to drive our lives. We simply need to know what we are doing and why. Nothing is automatic or foreordained.
15.Ultimately, you describe this book as character development for love rather than a dating manual. What does it mean to become the kind of person capable of authentic intimacy?
It’s a lifelong journey which, as the saying goes, begins with the first step.